Newbury Comics Garden City New York

Comic Book Store Details

Newbury Comics Garden City New York located in Garden City, New York has evolved from a traditional comic book store into more of a pop culture retail destination, where visitors note that comics have been moved to the back corner of the store while other merchandise like records, Funko Pops, and collectibles take center stage in the main shopping area.

While this comic book store does carry graphic novels and manga, people who visit this comic shop mention they frequently have sales on manga and graphic novels, though the selection appears to be more focused on current titles rather than extensive back catalogs.

Since the store has shifted its focus away from traditional comics, there aren’t many specific mentions of major comic brands or character selections in customer feedback.

How much do things cost here?

Visitors consistently express concern about the pricing at this comic book shop, with many noting that items are significantly marked up above MSRP, particularly for Pokemon cards and Funko Pops, while some long-time customers mention that prices have increased substantially since 2021.

How’s the product selection here?

The store offers a diverse range of products beyond just comics, with visitors highlighting an extensive selection of vinyl records, Funko Pops, plushies, trending toys, manga, anime merchandise, and pop culture items, though some express disappointment about the diminished focus on comic books.

Collectibles & Action Figures

This comic shop maintains a substantial collectibles section, featuring numerous Funko Pops, plushies from popular brands like Pusheen and Sanrio, Squishmallows, and various anime figures, making it more of a collectibles destination than a traditional comic book store.

Trading Cards, Manga, Anime & More

The store carries a significant selection of Pokemon cards (though frequently criticized for their pricing) and an extensive collection of Funko Pops, with visitors particularly noting the large variety of Pop figures available.

Manga and anime merchandise are major focus areas for this store, with people who visit this comic shop frequently praising the extensive selection of English manga titles and anime-related merchandise.

Is this place kid-friendly?

While there’s no direct mention of the store being specifically kid-friendly, the wide selection of toys, plushies, and Pokemon cards suggests it appeals to younger audiences, though parents might be concerned about the higher prices.