Lost toys and comics

Comic Book Store Details

Lost Toys and Comics located in Miller Place, New York offers an impressive selection of comics in a welcoming, neighborhood-style atmosphere that visitors describe as having a nostalgic clubhouse feel, where collectors regularly gather to talk shop and share their passion for comics and collectibles.

Beyond new comic releases, this comic book store proudly features classic graphic novels, particularly highlighting their Batman collection, which has received enthusiastic praise from visitors for its comprehensive selection.

When it comes to popular franchises, the store boasts an exceptional collection of Batman and Spider-Man comics and merchandise, with visitors specifically noting their impressive vintage Amazing Spider-Man collection as being one of the best available on Long Island.

How much do things cost here?

People who visit this comic shop consistently mention the fair and reasonable pricing across all products, with many noting that better deals can be found when purchasing multiple items, making it an accessible spot for both casual readers and serious collectors.

How’s the product selection here?

The store’s selection receives high praise from visitors who appreciate the diverse mix of both modern and vintage items, ranging from current comic releases to hard-to-find back issues, with many noting they’ve found long-sought-after comics in this well-organized shop.

Collectibles & Action Figures

This comic shop is a treasure trove of collectibles spanning multiple decades, featuring everything from pristine carded action figures from the ’80s and ’90s to vintage trading cards, with particularly impressive collections of G.I. Joe vehicles, MOTU figures and playsets, and wrestling figures, all available in various conditions from mint-in-box to loose items in bags.

Trading Cards, Manga, Anime & More

The store carries various trading cards, including Marvel Overpower cards and Fright Flicks collectible cards, though some visitors note they’d love to see Pokémon cards added to the selection.

While the store focuses primarily on comics and vintage toys, there’s no specific mention of anime, manga, or D&D products in the available reviews.

Is this place kid-friendly?

The comic book store maintains a welcoming environment for children, with multiple visitors highlighting the owner’s particularly kind and patient approach with young customers, making it an ideal spot for families to explore their comic interests together.